Which idea does the data on this chart support?
A. The United States had more casualties than any other nation.
B. France had the highest casualty rate of all the nations in the war.
C. Most countries did not suffer major casualties in World War I.
D. The war resulted in many casualties for all countries that took part.
Answer (2)
The United States did not have more casualties than any other nation; Germany, France and Great Britain had more.
We cannot determine if France had the highest casualty rate without population data.
The data shows that all countries listed suffered major casualties.
The war resulted in many casualties for all countries that took part, which is supported by the data. The war resulted in many casualties for all countries that took part.
Explanation
Analyzing the Data Let's analyze the data provided in the table to determine which statement is supported.
Evaluating the First Statement First, let's examine the statement: 'The United States had more casualties than any other nation.' Looking at the 'All Casualties' column, we see:
Great Britain: 3,190,235
Germany: 7,142,558
France: 6,160,800
United States: 323,018 Clearly, the United States had significantly fewer casualties than Great Britain, Germany, and France. Therefore, this statement is false.
Evaluating the Second Statement Next, let's consider the statement: 'France had the highest casualty rate of all the nations in the war.' The table provides the total casualties but not the population of each country during World War I. Without the population data, we cannot calculate the casualty rate (casualties per capita). Therefore, we cannot verify this statement with the given data.
Evaluating the Third Statement Now, let's analyze the statement: 'Most countries did not suffer major casualties in World War I.' Looking at the casualty numbers for each country, we see that Great Britain, Germany, and France all suffered millions of casualties. Even the United States, which had the fewest casualties among these four, still had over 300,000. These numbers suggest that all the listed countries suffered major casualties. Therefore, this statement is false.
Evaluating the Fourth Statement Finally, let's assess the statement: 'The war resulted in many casualties for all countries that took part.' As we observed in the previous step, all four countries listed in the table suffered a significant number of casualties. This supports the idea that the war resulted in many casualties for all countries that took part. Therefore, this statement is true.
Conclusion Based on our analysis, the data in the chart supports the idea that the war resulted in many casualties for all countries that took part.
Examples
Understanding the impact of historical events like World War I involves analyzing statistical data to draw meaningful conclusions. In this case, examining casualty figures helps us grasp the scale of human loss and the widespread impact of the war on participating nations. Analyzing such data is crucial in fields like history, political science, and sociology to understand the consequences of conflicts and inform future decisions about international relations and peacekeeping efforts. For example, the data shows that Germany suffered 7 , 142 , 558 casualties, while the United States suffered 323 , 018 casualties. This comparison highlights the varying degrees of impact on different nations.
The data supports the idea that 'The war resulted in many casualties for all countries that took part,' as significant casualties were reported for all major nations involved in World War I. Other options either misrepresent the casualty counts or lack necessary data for verification.
;
